Teddie · Peanut butter

Is Teddie Peanut Butter Healthy? Teddie Unsalted Smooth Nutrition Facts and Ingredients

Teddie Unsalted Smooth Peanut Butter package
Photo: fiejncakgjw, Open Food Facts, CC BY-SA 3.0

Short answer

Yes. Teddie Unsalted Smooth is one of the healthiest peanut butters you can buy, because the jar holds one ingredient: dry roasted peanuts. Two tablespoons (32 g) have 190 calories, 16 g of fat (2.5 g saturated), 8 g of protein, 3 g of fiber, 2 g of sugar with none added, and 0 mg of sodium. Nothing is added, so it is unprocessed or minimally processed (NOVA 1). The Truvi score (our method) is 85 out of 100. For comparison, Jif Creamy, with sugar and hydrogenated oils, scores 38. The only real catch is the calories: like every peanut butter, it is 5.9 calories per gram.

Truvi score

85/100

Excellent

  • Processing78/100

    NOVA 1; additives not listed

  • Nutrition89/100

    high nutritional quality (Nutri-Score A)

  • Overeating100/100

    calorie-dense 5.9kcal/g, whole food, not engineered

Our method, from the label. 75 and up is Excellent, 50 Good, 25 Fair, below 25 Bad. How the score works

Teddie peanut butter nutrition facts: is it healthy?

Here is one serving of Teddie Unsalted All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter, 2 tablespoons (32 g), from the label on teddie.com and the USDA branded foods database:

  • Calories. 190.
  • Fat. 16 g, of which 2.5 g saturated.
  • Carbohydrates. 7 g, with 3 g of fiber.
  • Sugar. 2 g, all from the peanuts. Added sugar: 0 g.
  • Protein. 8 g.
  • Sodium. 0 mg.

Against the daily values on US labels, one serving gives you 16% of the 50 g protein value and 11% of the 28 g fiber value. The saturated fat is 2.5 g, about 13% of the 20 g daily value. Most of the fat is the unsaturated fat that comes with peanuts.

What makes it a good peanut butter is what is missing: no sugar, no added oil, no emulsifier and no salt. Teddie says on its FAQ page that it does not add any sugar or any additional oils to its natural peanut butter. The 2 g of sugar on the label is the sugar that is naturally in peanuts.

What to watch is the portion. At 76% of calories from fat and 5.9 calories per gram, two level tablespoons are already 190 calories, and a heaped spoon is easy to eat straight from the jar.

Teddie peanut butter ingredients

The unsalted jar lists one ingredient: dry roasted peanuts. The regular Teddie All Natural Smooth adds "a pinch of salt", in Teddie's words. Otherwise the two jars are the same per serving: 190 calories, 16 g of fat, 8 g of protein and 3 g of fiber. The salted one has 125 mg of sodium per 2 tablespoons, about 5% of the 2,300 mg daily value; the unsalted one has none.

Because there is no hydrogenated oil to hold it together, the peanut oil slowly rises to the top. Teddie recommends stirring it back in. It does not need to be refrigerated, but Teddie suggests stirring it well and then keeping it in the fridge if you want to slow the oil separation.

Teddie is a Boston-area brand, founded in 1925 and made in Everett, Massachusetts. The unsalted smooth comes in 16, 26 and 36 oz jars. Teddie also sells chunky, organic and flaxseed versions.

Is Teddie peanut butter processed?

Only minimally. NOVA, the food-processing scale used in nutrition research, puts foods in group 1 when they are whole foods changed only by processes such as roasting or grinding that add no salt, sugar, oils or fats (Monteiro et al., 2019). Roasted peanuts ground into a paste, with nothing added, fit that group. Teddie Unsalted is NOVA 1.

Adding salt to a group 1 food makes it a processed food, group 3, in the same system. So regular salted Teddie is processed (NOVA 3), but still far from ultra-processed. A peanut butter becomes ultra-processed (NOVA 4) when the label has industrial ingredients such as hydrogenated or interesterified oils, or additives that change the texture, such as emulsifiers. That is the case for Jif Creamy, with fully hydrogenated vegetable oils and mono and diglycerides.

Why Teddie Unsalted scores 85 out of 100

The Truvi score (our method) is an opinion from the label. It combines how processed the food is, its nutritional quality and how easy it is to overeat.

  • Processing. 78 out of 100 here. NOVA 1, one ingredient, no additives.
  • Nutrition. 89 out of 100, Nutri-Score A on our calculation (the A to E grade used on packs in Europe). Protein, fiber and zero salt outweigh the calories and the 7.8 g of saturated fat per 100 g.
  • Overeating. 100 out of 100. It is calorie-dense, but it is a whole food, not a product engineered with added sugar, fat and salt.

The few nut butters that score higher are almond butters with less saturated fat. Among peanut butters, a jar with only peanuts on the label is as good as it gets.

Nut butters that score a little higher

No peanut butter in our data scores higher than Teddie Unsalted, so these are almond butters. All three are a single nut ground with nothing added (NOVA 1). The small gap comes mostly from almonds having less saturated fat than peanuts.

  • Unknown Brand Almond Butter

    Almond butter with no brand on the Open Food Facts record. One ingredient, almonds.

    NOVA 1 · Photo: kiliweb, CC BY-SA 3.0

    93Excellent

  • Trader Joe's Raw Almond Butter Creamy

    Trader Joe's Raw Almond Butter Creamy. One ingredient, raw almonds, no salt. Per 32 g serving: 190 calories, 7 g protein and 1 g saturated fat. Sold at Trader Joe's.

    NOVA 1 · Reported at Trader Joe's · Photo: kiliweb, CC BY-SA 3.0

    91Excellent

  • Kirkland Signature Creamy Almond

    Kirkland Signature Creamy Almond Butter. One ingredient, roasted almonds. Per 32 g serving: 200 calories, 7 g protein and 1.5 g saturated fat. Sold at Costco.

    NOVA 1 · Reported at Costco · Photo: bobjob, CC BY-SA 3.0

    91Excellent

Full ingredient list and nutrition

Dry roasted peanuts

Per 100 g
Energy594 kcal
Fat50 g
of which saturated7.8 g
Carbohydrates21.9 g
of which sugars6.3 g
Fiber9.4 g
Protein25 g
Salt0 g

Questions people ask

Is Teddie peanut butter healthy?

Yes, it is one of the healthiest peanut butters on US shelves. The unsalted smooth is only dry roasted peanuts: per 2 tablespoons 190 calories, 8 g of protein, 3 g of fiber, 0 g of added sugar and 0 mg of sodium. Truvi scores it 85 out of 100. Like any peanut butter it is calorie-dense, so the portion matters.

Is Teddie unsalted peanut butter healthier than the regular one?

Slightly, because it has no sodium. The regular Teddie All Natural Smooth adds a pinch of salt, 125 mg of sodium per 2 tablespoons. Calories, fat, protein, fiber and sugar are the same. Both have no added sugar and no added oil.

Is Teddie peanut butter healthier than Skippy?

Yes. Skippy Creamy lists roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil and salt, so it is ultra-processed (NOVA 4) because of the hydrogenated oil. Teddie Unsalted is peanuts only (NOVA 1), with no added sugar and no added oil.

Does Teddie natural peanut butter need to be refrigerated?

No. Teddie says its natural peanut butter does not need to be refrigerated. Keeping it in the fridge after stirring slows the oil separation, so many people do.

Why does Teddie peanut butter separate?

Because nothing is added to hold the peanut oil in. Jars like Jif and Skippy use hydrogenated oil to stop separation. In Teddie the oil slowly rises to the top, and you stir it back in.

Is Teddie peanut butter organic?

The unsalted smooth is not labeled organic. Teddie sells a separate Organic All Natural peanut butter in smooth and chunky.

Does Teddie peanut butter have added sugar?

No. The label shows 2 g of total sugar and 0 g of added sugar per 2 tablespoons. The sugar comes from the peanuts themselves.

Sources

  1. Teddie. Unsalted All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter, product page and nutrition facts.
  2. Teddie. All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter, product page and nutrition facts.
  3. Teddie. Frequently asked questions.
  4. Open Food Facts. Teddie All Natural Smooth Unsalted Peanut Butter (label data, ODbL).
  5. Open Food Facts. Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter (label data, ODbL).
  6. Monteiro CA et al. Ultra-processed foods: what they are and how to identify them. Public Health Nutrition, 2019.
  7. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels.

Label data: USDA FoodData Central, branded foods (manufacturer label data), barcode 0071018010176. Score: Truvi score (truviScore v10), balanced setting.

Automated estimate from the product label, an opinion, not a statement of fact about the manufacturer. Ingredient and nutrition data from Open Food Facts (ODbL) may be incomplete or inaccurate. Based on published food-science systems (NOVA · Fazzino · Nutri-Score). Not medical advice.

Spotted a mistake? Email info@truviapp.com with the barcode and we will review it.

Check any product before you buy it

Point your phone at a barcode in the store. Truvi shows the score, what's inside and a better option on the same shelf.

Download on theApp Store
  • Truvi app showing a product's score
  • Truvi app showing better options on the same shelf
  • Truvi app explaining a product's ingredients